[-] Text Size [+] | Update Donation/Contact Info | Home

   
   

A Few Good White Men – From Central Canada

Mar 26, 1998

For Immediate Release

Ottawa – Patronage-style appointments to the CBC Board of Directors should fade to black, according to Friends of Canadian Broadcasting. Research found less than 1% of appointments to the CBC and the CRTC had been drawn from Canada's visible minorities. The FCB has written to the Prime Minister and MPs urging them to overhaul the process. Friends recommends appointments to the CBC and CRTC should:

  • be based on published criteria including task descriptions,
  • reflect regional, linguistic, gender and skills balance,
  • include a public nominations process, and
  • be subject to parliamentary review and confirmation.

"There needs to be more openness, opportunities for external nominations to be received and a means for Parliament to validate candidates," said FCB spokesperson Ian Morrison.

"The CBC's budget exceeds one billion dollars. CRTC decisions impact our lives every day. But when the number one qualification for running these major corporation is political affiliation, there's a problem. The current system is completely opaque to the public, the selection criteria are hidden and there's no interview process. And the historical evidence paints a bleak picture. If the Government needed a recruiting slogan it might be: "A few good white men from central Canada."

Research commissioned by the FCB reviewed appointments to the CBC over the past 62 years. Author, Arlan Gates, found that women comprised only 19% of appointments to the CBC Board, rising to 25% during Mr. Chrétien's watch. Ontario and Quebec has been home to 61% of appointments – and surprisingly, this weighting has increased over the past 20 years – with Mr. Chrétien appointing 75% from central Canada. It was also found that only one CBC Director has come from a visible minority.

"On one hand the public would want to see these major institutions run by qualified individuals with suitable experience drawn from every region and representative of our country. On the other hand, we see an old boys network choreographed out of the Prime Minister's Office," said Morrison.

Of the 17 appointments made by Mr. Chrétien, none has been from the three prairie provinces.

Mr. Gates found that of those appointments where political affiliation was known, 92% of CBC appointments were made from those with the same political affiliation as the government which appointed them (83% among CRTC appointees).

"Publicly owned institutions such as the CBC, and regulatory agencies such as the CRTC have a major influence on our lives, not just in terms of the dollars and cents issues, but in shaping the way we see our communities, our country and the world. Some excellent appointments have been made, but these exceptions are not the rule," said Mr. Morrison.

"We have written to Members of Parliament seeking their support for changes to the system. Ultimately, it will take the will of the Prime Minister to bring about change. Perhaps he needs encouragement," said Morrison. "There are many options we've looked at from around the world and it's clear that patronage appointments – Chrétien style to principal cultural institutions are outdated."

– 30 –

For information:

Jim Thompson (613) 567-9592

Related Links

See also:

Appointments to the CBC and CRTC Criteria and Process